What the Cats can learn from the previous matchup with the Sooners to keep their season alive

Oklahoma and Kentucky will meet once again, this will be number 4 on the year, in the SEC baseball tournament. Kentucky must win this game if they want to make the NCAA tournament.
Kentucky baseball head coach Nick Mingione walks to the pitchers mound during a NCAA baseball game between Tennessee and Kentucky at Lindsey Nelson Stadium in Knoxville, Tenn., on April 18, 2025.
Kentucky baseball head coach Nick Mingione walks to the pitchers mound during a NCAA baseball game between Tennessee and Kentucky at Lindsey Nelson Stadium in Knoxville, Tenn., on April 18, 2025. | Angelina Alcantar/News Sentinel / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

Season on the Brink: Kentucky Baseball Faces Must-Win SEC Opener vs. Oklahoma

Game details and streaming:

Kentucky vs Oklahoma
SEC opening round
First pitch 2:00 PM
TV: SEC Network

You can watch live on TV, no need to break out an app. And best of all you can get a free trial to YoutubeTV by clicking here. You can also watch via Hulu with live TV by clicking here or if you prefer Fubo by clicking here.

It wasn’t supposed to come to this—not after sweeping Oklahoma just two weeks ago. But now, with three straight soul-crushing losses to Vanderbilt and an RPI of 36, Kentucky baseball (29–23) walks into Hoover, Alabama with its season hanging by a thread.

Kentucky baseball
Kentucky baseball coach Nick Mingione during the NCAA college baseball game against Tennessee on April 20, 2025, in Knoxville, Tenn. | Saul Young/News Sentinel / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

Tuesday’s SEC Tournament opener against the Sooners, who sit at 33–19 and a safer No. 27 in the RPI, is more than just a rematch. It’s a potential final exam for Nick Mingione’s team. A loss may not doom Oklahoma, but for Kentucky? Four straight losses, a one-and-done exit could easily leave the Cats on the outside looking in come Selection Monday.

Familiar opponent, fresh stakes

The Wildcats swept Oklahoma in a regular-season series earlier this month, winning 4–3, 8–5, 7-2 in Lexington. While that gives Kentucky some confidence heading into the rematch, postseason baseball has a way of exposing every flaw. And after reviewing those wins, there are some clear takeaways Kentucky needs to revisit if it wants to extend its season.

OU baseball
Oklahoma coach Skip Johnson sits beside Jason Walk (1) in the dugout before a college Bedlam baseball game between the University of Oklahoma Sooners (OU) and the Oklahoma State University Cowboys (OSU) at O'Brate Stadium in Stillwater, Okla., Tuesday, April 15, 2025. | BRYAN TERRY/THE OKLAHOMAN / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

1. Limit free passes—again

In the 3 victories over the Sooners, Kentucky’s pitchers issued just 11 total walks. Compare that to 28 strikeouts over the weekend, and the formula becomes clear: when UK throws strikes, they win. Oklahoma drew 6 walks in Game 1 but couldn’t cash them in. They only left 10 runners on base because Kentucky forced contact and made plays. Keep the walks low, and the Cats keep the season alive.

2. Schwartz, Herrera, and Hage must carry the load

Patrick Herrera and Ryan Schwartz were lethal in the second game of the Oklahoma series, combining for 6 RBIs and 2 extra-base hits. Cole Hage added a 2-run homer in Game 1. With offensive consistency still an issue at times, Mingione desperately needs his veterans to stabilize the middle of the order. If Herrera and Schwartz can create traffic, the offense has life.

3. Beware of Easton Carmichael and Scott Mudler

Oklahoma catcher Easton Carmichael and DH Scott Mudler did real damage in the earlier series, each hitting a home run and combining for 6 RBIs. Carmichael, in particular, has been a steady force all season. If Kentucky wants to hold off an Oklahoma comeback or rally, they’ll have to keep both bats quiet—especially late in games.

4. Bullpen clarity: Ride the hot arms

Jackson Nove and Simon Gregersen were excellent out of the bullpen in Lexington. Nove threw 3.1 shutout innings, and Gregersen picked up a save with a scoreless ninth. In a high-pressure setting like Hoover, reliable relievers are golden. Mingione needs to have a quick hook if the starter falters and go straight to the arms he trusts and they must deliver.

What's at stake

At 29–23 and just 12–17 in the SEC, Kentucky’s resume is fragile. The RPI is borderline. They’re just 7–10 against top-50 RPI teams and have no series wins over ranked opponents. A victory over Oklahoma likely keeps the Wildcats in the NCAA conversation heading into the double-elimination portion of the tournament. A loss? It might just be the end of the road.

Gregersen
Kentucky's Simon Gregersen (40) yells out in victory after striking out Tennessee's Blake Grimmer (14) to win the NCAA college baseball game in Knoxville, Tenn., on April 20, 2025. | Saul Young/News Sentinel / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

Final word

Kentucky swept the Sooners once. They’ll need one more win—this time with everything on the line. The margin is razor-thin. But as this team has shown all season, when they pitch to contact, play clean defense, and get production from their core bats, they can beat anyone. That version of Kentucky must show up today. Or this season, and possibly the NCAA dream, is over.