Grading Mark Pope's up and down first season as Kentucky basketball coach

The Cats got back to the Sweet 16, and handled various injuries along the way. What grade does Mark Pope get after his season ends?
NCAA Men's Basketball Tournament - First & Second Rounds - Milwaukee - Practice Day
NCAA Men's Basketball Tournament - First & Second Rounds - Milwaukee - Practice Day | Stacy Revere/GettyImages

Mark Pope’s first season as Kentucky’s head coach was a rollercoaster filled with unexpected triumphs, frustrating losses, and a whole lot of intrigue. Taking over one of the most high-pressure jobs in college basketball, Pope had just two months to build a roster from scratch. He dealt with key injuries, navigated an SEC gauntlet, and still found a way to guide the Wildcats to the Sweet 16.

So, how do we grade his first year in Lexington? Let’s break it down.

🏗️ Roster Construction: B

Pope hit the ground running, assembling a team in just two months after taking over. He added impact transfers, blended young talent with experience, and built a fast-paced, high-scoring offense.

However, the team wasn’t without flaws. Depth, especially in the backcourt, became an issue when Jaxson Robinson and Kerr Kriisa went down with injuries. Even so, the roster competed with the best in the country—a strong testament to Pope’s ability to quickly build a team in the transfer portal era.

📈 Regular Season Performance: B+

Record: 21-10 (SEC: 11-7, 6th place)

Kentucky’s season felt like a tale of two teams. On their best nights, the Wildcats were electric, picking up marquee wins over:

Duke (77-72)

Tennessee x2 (78-73, 75-64)

Florida (106-100 OT)

Gonzaga (90-89)

But then, there were the head-scratching losses:

Vanderbilt (74-69) – A game Kentucky squandered after leading late.

Arkansas (89-79) – A winnable home game that slipped away to Calipari.

Texas (82-78) – Another missed opportunity.

Ohio State (85-65) – Perhaps the worst loss of any Pope suffered this year, the team no showed in New York.

The inconsistency cost them a higher SEC finish, but finishing sixth in the toughest conference in America is far from a failure.

🎤 Handling the Kentucky Spotlight: A+

If there’s one thing Pope absolutely nailed, it was handling the fans, media, and pressure that comes with leading Big Blue Nation.

Press Conferences – Pope was charismatic, insightful, and engaging every time he stepped to the podium.

Fan Engagement – He embraced Kentucky’s history, frequently talking about what it means to wear the blue and white.

Team-First Mentality – He never made excuses, even when dealing with key injuries or tough losses.

Kentucky fans have been hungry for a coach who “gets it”, and Pope absolutely does.

🏆 Postseason Performance: A-

NCAA Tournament:

✔️ First Round: Defeated Troy (76-57) – No drama. Business-like win.

✔️ Second Round: Beat Illinois (84-75) – A fantastic performance to take down a higher-seeded team.

Sweet 16: Lost to Tennessee (78-65) – The third matchup with the Vols proved to be too much.

Kentucky made it farther than many expected, and while a loss to an SEC rival in the Sweet 16 stings, it was still a strong showing in March.

📊 Final Grade: B+

Mark Pope’s first season wasn’t perfect, but considering the circumstances, it was a solid debut. He brought energy back to the program, won some huge games, and got Kentucky to the second weekend of the NCAA Tournament.

Still, the next step is clear:

➡️ Win the SEC or SEC Tournament.

➡️ Beat the teams you’re supposed to beat.

➡️ Make a deeper NCAA Tournament run.

If Pope can build on Year 1, Big Blue Nation might have something special brewing in Lexington.

🔥 What’s Next?

Recruiting and transfer portal season will be key for Pope’s long-term success. Can he add the right pieces to take Kentucky back to Final Four contention?

Stay tuned to WBN for all the latest updates on Kentucky basketball as the offseason unfolds!