Cutter Boley’s first career start was never going to be a perfect evaluation. The level of competition in Eastern Michigan is nowhere near what Zach Calzada faced against Toledo and Ole Miss. But Saturday’s game was designed to do two things: get the offense confidence and give the staff a real look at their sophomore quarterback.
So, how did he do? The final numbers look great, but the performance itself was a mixed bag of promising flashes and teachable moments.
The good
The box score tells a story of success. Boley finished an efficient 12-of-21 for 240 yards and two touchdowns, with no interceptions. His 11.4 yards-per-attempt shows he was pushing the ball downfield and creating the explosive plays this offense has lacked. He looked especially comfortable throwing to his tight ends, who caught five of his passes, including both touchdowns—Kentucky's first two passing scores of the entire season. He also showed mobility, rushing five times for 24 yards to extend plays. This was the clear positive.
The bad
While he didn't throw an interception, he was certainly fortunate. There were at least two passes that should have been picked off. One was a deep out route thrown into double coverage where the defensive back undercut the route and simply dropped the ball. Another was an RPO where he failed to see a linebacker who should have had an easy interception.
Beyond the dangerous throws, there were the execution issues. The fumbled snap exchange with Jager Burton inside the 5-yard line was a costly mistake that turned a sure touchdown into a field goal. These are the kinds of self-inflicted wounds that get you beat in the SEC.
The final verdict
This start was exactly what it needed to be: a learning experience. Boley showed the immense talent and upside that makes him the quarterback of the future. He also showed the decision-making lapses and inexperience that are typical for a young player. He got the win, built confidence, and now has a bye week to work out the kinks.
Grade: B-
Drew Holbrook is an avid Kentucky fan who has been covering the Cats for over 10 years. In his free time, he spends time with his family, and watching Premier League soccer. Micah 7:7. #UpTheAlbion