Mitch Barnhart has led UK Athletics for over two decades with notable successes across several sports. Under his leadership, Kentucky’s athletic department has achieved competitive rankings in different sports and won championships, including NCAA titles in men’s basketball and volleyball. However, some Wildcats fans have voiced frustrations with Barnhart’s approach to coaching contracts. Below, we will dive into the current head coaches' contracts for baseball, football, basketball, and women's basketball. We will not be discussing the UK swim controversy, but it, too, is a black eye on the legacy of Mitch Barnhart.
Before UK thinks about firing stoops they should fire Mitch Barnhart.
— Juicy Jimmy 🏳️🌈 (@juicyjimmy) October 27, 2024
This makes twice within a short amount of time he has put the school in a terrible position with a head coach they can’t afford to fire and you have to hope they step down.
1. Baseball
Nick Mingione’s contract reflects Barnhart’s tendency to reward stability. Mingione earns $1.175 million annually with a unique auto-extension clause that Mitch seems to love: each season Kentucky makes it to the NCAA Tournament, he gains an extra year on his contract automatically. In June, Kentucky won its first-ever game in Omaha.
2. Women's Basketball
Previous coach Kyra Elzy also has a hefty contract of $2.475 million remaining until June 2027. Hired after Matthew Mitchell’s retirement, Elzy had ups and downs before Barnhart had to fire her. New coach Kenny Brooks comes over from Virginia Tech, where he will make an annual salary of just under $1.5 million.
3. Men's Basketball
John Calipari came close to leaving for UCLA, but Mitch Barnhart, feeling the urgency to keep him, extended a lifetime contract offer. This deal allowed Calipari the option to step down anytime to become an ambassador for the program. However, since the COVID year, his production has declined, with disappointing early exits from the NCAA tournament leading many fans to believe it was time for a change. The high buyout clause in Calipari’s contract, however, limited this possibility. As it turns out, some believe Barnhart was fortunate that Cal ultimately decided to depart for Arkansas.
Before Calipari, Mitch had issues with Billy Gillispie's contract or lack thereof. He worked under a Memorandum of Understanding, which meant that when he was fired, the school tried not to pay him anything. Eventually, it paid out just under $3 million to settle.
That brings us to Mark Pope. Pope will rake in $5.5 million per year for five years. His contract also has a clause for an auto extension (thanks, Mitch). If Kentucky gets to the Sweet 16, he will get an auto extension year. If Kentucky does not get to the Sweet 16, he will get a $250K raise that year instead.
4. Football
Perhaps the most controversial contract, Barnhart extended head coach Mark Stoops, who now earns $9 million a year. Stoops also receives an automatic one-year extension every season he wins at least seven games and a two-year extension for reaching 10 wins in a year. Additionally, each SEC win beyond two games earns him a $100K bonus. This clause has made Stoops untouchable, with over a $40 million dollar buyout, especially considering the program has taken steps back, losing 11 of 13 home SEC games
In the end, Mitch Barnhart’s approach to contracts, emphasizing stability and rewarding past performance, has brought Kentucky Athletics some consistency, but not without raising questions. Craig Skinner won a national title in Volleyball, the men's soccer team has made runs in the NCAA tournament, and cheerleading continues its dominance, but there have been flops, too. The heavy buyout clauses and auto-extension provisions, especially in football and basketball, have started to show the reasons why they are very coach-friendly.
The contract structure, which seemingly prioritizes stability over flexibility, may give coaches a sense of comfort that just doesn’t translate to the best outcomes in terms of team success. As fans, we can appreciate Barnhart’s legacy of loyalty and commitment to the staff. We get it, he wants to win and do it in the right way, but it’s fair to wonder if a more performance-driven AD could get Kentucky greater accomplishments. Kentucky’s program is ripe with potential in a lot of sports, but a balance between stability and accountability may be the key to bringing out the best in our teams.